Court case(1878) 4 App Cas 13

Ward v. Hobbs Ward v. Hobbs (the pigs sold 'with all faults')

(1878) 4 App Cas 13 · House of Lords · 1878

PrincipleCaveat emptor: absent fraud, a duty to speak or a warranty, the seller is not liable for defects the buyer could have discovered.

Facts

Hobbs sent pigs to a public auction where they were sold 'with all faults', subject to a condition that no warranty would be given. Ward bought them. The pigs were suffering from typhoid fever, as Hobbs knew; several died and they infected Ward's other pigs. Ward sued, contending that by exposing diseased pigs for sale Hobbs had impliedly represented them to be sound, or at least was bound to disclose the disease.

Held

The House of Lords held for the seller. Mere silence as to a defect is not a misrepresentation; the seller was under no duty to disclose, and sending the pigs to market was not a representation of soundness, particularly as they were sold 'with all faults'. The buyer had the opportunity to examine and chose to buy; the rule of caveat emptor applied and he had no remedy.

Loading the full case…